This headband-sporting New Yorker wowed the judges in Season 1 with his billy goat warbling of an original composition. His wounded-bird dance moves didn’t help, either. After being dubbed by Simon as "the worst singer in America” (the first person to win that award from Cowell!) he shuffled on home as one of the show’s first anti-heroes. -Jeff Royer
The opinions expressed are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Comcast.