THEN: Alyson Hannigan as 'Michelle Flaherty'
When Jim's plan to take Nadia to prom falls through, he asks the only person who hasn't heard his unflattering reputation — a flute-loving band geek named Michelle. As it turns out, Michelle is well aware of Jim's online exploits. —XFINITY Entertainment Staff (Photo: Getty)
The opinions expressed are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Comcast.